reply to thread or comment
Question asked by Richard Frank - 12/9/2014 at 6:10 AM
Unanswered
I was wonder what exactly the idea for the difference is between comment and reply?
Richard Frank Replied
comment
Richard Frank Replied
reply
Richard Frank Replied
comment
Steve Reid Replied
This is posted as a Reply not a comment.
Steve Reid Replied
These are both posted as comments
Richard Frank Replied
indeed.. Steve :)
 
but .. why a difference between comment and reply? I think it's a bit confusing
 
every forum I have known there is only a reply option and replies are also comments on a post.
when you want to respond to a specific reply there is a quote option.
Steve Reid Replied
The difference is that a reply can be liked and with a comment you can't do anything. It seems like it's not really thought out well that's for sure.
 
Comments have no place in a forum. We need to be able to either vote up or like any post at all. Right now it seems this system is not complete.
Richard Frank Replied
it's the third of fourth forum I have used here.. now ST is inventing the wheel again.
 
I think ST has some stocks in mouse scroll wheel producers :D  .. just kidding.
Steve Reid Replied
yeah, in reinventing the wheel I guess they're are trying square first before circle, lol
Steve Reid Replied
I didn't seem this when I posted my comment... ;)
Andy Schmidt Replied
Agreed with everyone's sentiments.
 
I don't see "comments" as being useful in the context in a forum.  In fact, I found myself first "commenting" unintentionally, then realizing it lost all the formatting (such as paragraphs/line breaks), then reposting as a reply, etc. Comments are just another/unexpected twist confusing occasional users.
 
And, yes, I've too noticed them changing forum software from time-to-time. Prettier, but, if anything, now harder to navigate to problems related to a particular product. It's "nicer on the eye" but the utility value has decreased, in my opinion.
 
 

Reply to Thread

Enter the verification text